Jun 16, 4:19 PM

Geneva Voters Ban Religious Symbols for Local Politicians – But the Courts Will Have the Final Word

With 51.4% in favor, cantonal and municipal parliamentarians can no longer wear conspicuous religious symbols during debates. Opponents say the ban is unconstitutional.

By

Geneva's voters have spoken. By a narrow margin of 51.4 percent, they approved a ban on conspicuous religious symbols for members of the cantonal and municipal parliaments during debates. The proposal, which applies to all religious symbols including headscarves, crosses, and kippahs, was backed by the SVP, FDP, Center Party, and the Mouvement Citoyen Genevois.

The ban does not apply to members of the State Council or municipal executives, who are already bound by religious neutrality under the 2019 cantonal law on the separation of religion and state. Judges and the Court of Auditors are also covered by that law. The new measure extends the neutrality requirement to parliamentarians.

Supporters argued that religious neutrality ensures objective debates and upholds secularism. FDP Grand Councilor Céline Zuber-Roy, who campaigned for the ban, described it as a limited restriction – no more than ten hours a month – that does not exclude anyone. She drew attention before the vote by wearing a sieve on her head during a council session, mockingly illustrating how distracting conspicuous religious items could be. SVP Grand Councilor Stéphane Florey, who initiated the constitutional amendment, said he was pleased that voters had reaffirmed the principle of religious neutrality, just as they had done in the 2019 vote on the religion law.

But the State Council, the left, the Libertés et Justice sociale party, and several associations opposed the ban. They argued that it infringes on fundamental freedoms. State Councilor Carole-Anne Kast of the Social Democrats expressed regret that voters had approved what she considers an unconstitutional change. Opponents also noted that no problems related to religious symbols have ever been reported in the Grand Council. In municipal bodies, only one elected Green Party representative currently wears a headscarf.

The legal battle is far from over. Two Green Party Grand Councilors had already filed an appeal before Sunday's vote, arguing that the ban constitutes a disproportionate violation of religious freedom. One of them, Julien Nicolet-dit-Félix, said he could not understand how the judges could rule differently now than they did in 2019. At that time, the Constitutional Chamber excluded parliamentarians from the neutrality requirement, reasoning that they represent not the canton but society and its diversity. That argument was central to the opponents' case.

The Constitutional Chamber will now have to revisit the issue. The ban applies to all religious symbols – headscarves, crosses, and kippahs – without targeting any specific religion. But opponents saw it as an Islamophobic attack. Feminist and anti-racist groups denounced what they called harassment of Muslim women.

For now, the ban is in place. But the courts will decide whether it survives. The narrow margin of victory and the legal challenges ahead suggest that Geneva's debate over religious symbols is far from settled. The parliamentarians who opposed the ban are already preparing their case. And in the end, it will be the judges – not the voters – who have the final word.

Written by Thomas Nussbaumer thomas.nussbaumer@alpineweekly.com