Jul 20, 10:02 PM

Switzerland’s surrogacy ban works best when someone else does the paperwork

Home rules remain restrictive, but children born through surrogacy abroad can still be recognised in Switzerland — a compromise that keeps the ban intact while shifting the ethical burden elsewhere.

By

Switzerland’s surrogacy ban works best when someone else does the paperwork

Switzerland has found a familiar way of handling a difficult question: prohibit it at home, tolerate the consequences elsewhere. Surrogacy is banned on Swiss territory, but if intended parents go abroad, they are not punished. The child can later be brought to Switzerland and recognised or adopted there. It is the kind of arrangement that looks tidy on paper and slightly less so in real life.

The legal path is possible, but hardly elegant. A child born abroad through surrogacy can be recognised in Switzerland by the social parents, yet the exact route depends on the family situation. In a heterosexual couple using the father’s sperm, the father can recognise the child and the mother must adopt. If sperm donation is involved, both parents must adopt. For a gay couple, the biological father can recognise the child, while the other parent must go through stepchild adoption.

That procedure creates a period in which the child may have only one legal parent, or none at all. If one parent dies during that time, the consequences can affect pensions and inheritance. So much for the comforting idea that law can simply look away until the paperwork is finished. The child, naturally, does not get to pause the legal system while adults sort out their arrangements.

Jürg Streuli, a medical ethicist and member of the National Ethics Commission, says there is a legal and ethical tension in this Swiss approach. In his view, the domestic ban is meant to protect the surrogate mother, while recognition of parent-child relationships created abroad serves the protection of the already born child. He argues that this distinction is not necessarily incoherent, but rather an attempt to take two different protected interests seriously at the same time. He also says personally that action is needed.

The Federal Council is not eager to copy Italy and criminalise surrogacy tourism. In its response to a parliamentary initiative, it said that establishing the facts would have to happen largely abroad, which would create major difficulties. It also feared that convicting intended parents could endanger the child’s welfare. That leaves Switzerland with a ban that stops at the border and a state that prefers not to test how much moral consistency its own system can bear.

The international market is already there. Surrogacy is allowed in countries including Great Britain, the Netherlands, Belgium, Poland, Georgia, Israel and some US states. The conditions vary sharply. In Israel, only citizens may use the service. In Great Britain, Canada and Australia, no profit may be made, while in India, Ukraine and parts of the United States commercial markets have developed.

One possible answer would be to allow surrogacy for Swiss citizens under strict conditions, as Israel does. Pink Cross, the umbrella group for gay and bisexual men, supports such a model, and Streuli also considers it ethically worth examining. The logic is straightforward enough: if Switzerland writes high standards into law, it could reduce the incentive to go abroad and strengthen protection for everyone involved.

The National Ethics Commission reached a similar view in 2013, when it recommended reconsidering the ban. Its conditions were clear: surrogate mothers must be fully informed, must give free consent, and must receive legal protection and high-quality medical care. It also called for an altruistic model to prevent commercialisation and for independent representation of the surrogate mother’s interests. That is a demanding list, which may be precisely why the current compromise remains so attractive. One can always preserve principles more easily when someone else is left to deal with the consequences.

Written by Andreas Hofer andreas.hofer@alpineweekly.com