Jul 21, 8:01 AM

NT child protection missed the danger, but still cannot explain the death

An interim review says repeated domestic violence risks around Kumanjayi Little Baby were not properly assessed, even as investigators stop short of linking those failures to her alleged murder.

By

NT child protection missed the danger, but still cannot explain the death

The Northern Territory’s child protection system has once again done what such systems often do after a tragedy: it has produced a report that is frank about failure, and cautious to the point of paralysis about responsibility. In the case of Kumanjayi Little Baby, the interim review says the state missed repeated domestic violence risks and left her mother carrying the burden of protection almost alone. Yet the same report declines to draw a direct line from those failures to the five-year-old girl’s death. Bureaucracy, one suspects, remains a devoted student of the fine print.

The review was tabled in parliament on Tuesday, just as changes to the Care and Protection of Children Act passed through the chamber, despite the resignation this month of the NT’s children’s commissioner over the legislation. The timing is awkward, though not exactly surprising. Child protection reform in Australia tends to arrive only after the system has already failed, which is a costly way to discover that prevention is cheaper than mourning.

According to the report, the key problem was not a lack of legal powers or protective tools. It was that risk was not identified, assessed and acted on quickly enough. The family had been the subject of multiple child safety notifications linked to alleged domestic and family violence by the girl’s father against her mother, including while she was pregnant. Even so, the review found that a domestic and family violence-informed risk assessment was not carried out as part of the child protection process.

The review team, led by former New South Wales police commissioner Karen Webb and former acting NT anti-corruption commissioner Greg Shanahan, said the department’s approach relied too heavily on subjective judgment. Different workers could rate the same case differently, they noted, and those ratings then shaped the safety plan. The report warns that this sort of inconsistency is likely to understate risk and overstate safety, which is a poor trade in any system meant to protect children.

The document also says the department failed to recognise the cumulative effect of repeated reports, including the frequency, severity and escalation of the violence over time. In plain terms, the pattern was there, but the system did not read it properly. Kumanjayi Little Baby’s mother, the report says, was effectively left to protect her children while also facing domestic and family violence herself, without the department adequately identifying the danger posed by the perpetrator’s behaviour.

The girl, known after her death as Kumanjayi Little Baby for cultural reasons, was allegedly abducted and murdered in April by Jefferson Lewis, 47, a man unknown to her or her family. Her disappearance led to a five-day search before her body was found, and the case prompted grief across the country, along with hundreds of vigils. Lewis has been charged with murder and is due back in court this month.

The interim report makes seven recommendations, including better training, more staff, improved risk assessment and stronger safety planning. Those are sensible enough, though one might ask why such basics still need to be rediscovered after every catastrophe. The deeper dispute now sits over the NT’s child protection laws, which critics say could weaken the Aboriginal child placement principle, a safeguard created in response to the Stolen Generations to keep Indigenous children connected to family and community.

That concern is no longer being voiced only by advocates. On Monday, the children’s ministers of every state and territory except the NT and Queensland, together with federal families minister Tanya Plibersek, issued a joint statement backing the principle. Catherine Liddle, chief executive of SNAICC, said that such a statement from the rest of the country should be a warning to the NT government that it has badly misread the moment. On this evidence, she has a point.

Written by Sandy van Dongen sandy.vandongen@alpineweekly.com