Nov 17, 5:24 PM

Five EU Countries Want to Send Rejected Asylum Seekers to Rwanda

Germany, Austria, Greece, Denmark, and the Netherlands have agreed on a deportation hub in Kigali. Rights groups call it a "cruel black hole." Rwanda says it wants a second chance for the migrants — and payment only for the costs.

By

Five European countries have unveiled plans to send rejected asylum seekers to a deportation hub in Rwanda, drawing condemnation from rights groups who say the scheme will leave vulnerable people at risk of abuse.

Under the plan, which is still being negotiated with Kigali, Germany, Austria, Greece, Denmark, and the Netherlands would send people to a centre where they could choose to return home, settle in Rwanda, or move to another country where they have the right to stay.

"I think it will be a game changer, making us able to confront the massive challenges of illegal migration," Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said at a press conference in Vienna alongside her Austrian counterpart and ministers from the countries involved.

The five countries have been working towards a so-called return hub for several months — part of a broader push inside the European Union to increase deportations and curb irregular migration. With elections approaching in several EU countries, centrist governments have been toughening immigration policies to try to counter growing public support for far-right parties.

In a joint statement, 47 aid, trade union, and rights groups urged the five countries to abandon the plan — echoing criticism of a similar migration scheme between Britain and Rwanda in the early 2020s. The plan "signals that Member States accept the risk of serious human rights violations against one of the most marginalized groups in society, in return for a deterrence goal that evidence clearly suggests they will not reach," the statement read.

Although officials say such a hub would only handle about 100 people at a time, the countries championing it say it would send an important signal that they hope will discourage would-be migrants from making the perilous journey to Europe. The project follows the approval of the EU's new Return Regulation, designed to speed up deportations.

The scheme differs from Britain's abandoned Rwanda plan in one key respect: it would apply only to migrants who have exhausted all legal avenues to remain in the EU, rather than those whose claims are still being processed.

Rwanda has positioned itself as a destination for migrants whom Western countries want to remove, despite longstanding concerns about its own human rights record. "Under this partnership, Rwanda would provide a second chance to people who no longer have the legal right to remain in the partner countries," Rwandan Interior Minister Vincent Biruta said. He added that Rwanda was not looking to be paid for the arrangement, but that partner countries would meet the cost of relocation and the integration of anyone who chose to stay.

President Paul Kagame has won praise from Western and regional leaders for helping end Rwanda's 1994 genocide and rebuilding the country into an investment destination. However, critics accuse his government of suppressing dissent and supporting rebels alleged to have committed killings, rapes, and other abuse in neighbouring Democratic Republic of Congo. Rights advocates also point to restrictions on political freedoms and free speech. Freedom House rates Rwanda "Not Free" and cites the suppression of political dissent through surveillance, intimidation, arbitrary detention, and torture.

"There is a real danger that the Rwanda deal will, with its limited chance for scrutiny, become a cruel black hole for human rights," Amnesty International said in a statement.

The United States began transferring migrants to Rwanda last year under an agreement allowing it to deport up to 250 people. Britain abandoned its own plan after it was ruled unlawful by the country's Supreme Court in 2023; Kigali sought a £50 million payment after the UK scheme was scrapped. During a September visit to Kigali, two European Parliament lawmakers were shown facilities earmarked for Britain's abandoned scheme that could potentially house migrants transferred from EU countries, including a hotel.

For now, the plan is a signal — to voters, to would-be migrants, and to the rest of Europe. Five governments have decided that the way to prove they are serious about migration is to send people to a country thousands of kilometres away, where they will have no legal right to stay and where their future will depend on the goodwill of a government that does not answer to European courts. Whether that is deterrence or abandonment is a question each of those five capitals will have to answer.

Written by Andreas Hofer andreas.hofer@alpineweekly.com