
Europe’s job market is still too fond of fragility
Eurofound’s latest figures show that vulnerability remains widespread across the EU, with Spain far ahead of the pack and low pay still doing much of the damage.

Europe likes to advertise social cohesion; its labour market, rather less so. Eurofound’s latest report says 18.8% of jobs in the European Union were vulnerable in 2021, meaning they failed on at least one of three counts: pay, security or workplace rights. That is close to one in five jobs, which makes the usual ceremonial talk of “quality” sound a little thin.
The trend is not entirely bleak. Vulnerability rose from 21.4% in 2009 to 23.8% in 2014, as the financial crisis pushed more people into involuntary temporary and part-time work. Since 2016, the rate has fallen steadily and is now below its pre-crisis level. Eurofound’s own 2024 survey overview, published in April, tells the same story: some improvement, persistent gaps, and a labour market that still distributes risk with remarkable consistency.
The geography is uneven in a way that should surprise nobody. Spain has the highest vulnerability rate at 29%. Portugal and Luxembourg follow at 25%, and Italy stands at 24%. Hungary records 17%, while Malta and Bulgaria are both at 18%. Six countries — Cyprus, Czechia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania and Sweden — were excluded because 2021 data were unavailable.
The causes differ by region. In continental countries such as Germany and Austria, and across central and eastern Europe, low pay is the main problem. In Bulgaria, the report’s 2019 breakdown found that low pay accounted for nearly three quarters of vulnerability. In Mediterranean and Nordic states, insecurity plays a larger role, with involuntary temporary and part-time work dominating. Ireland is the extreme case, where insecurity makes up 56% of the total, the highest share in the EU.
Luxembourg’s place near the top is less mysterious once one remembers that pay is measured against each country’s own median income. Relative comparisons have a habit of producing odd results, though not usually odd enough to comfort anyone.
The report is clearest on who carries the burden. Women, young workers, migrants, Roma, people with disabilities and LGBT+ individuals are all more likely to hold vulnerable jobs, held back by discrimination, care duties and, for migrants, legal obstacles and unrecognised qualifications. Education offers protection. In Hungary, 58% of workers with low education are vulnerable, compared with just 6% of graduates. Time helps too: each additional year in the labour market reduces the risk by one percentage point, or roughly 20% over a 20-year career.
The damage comes when vulnerabilities pile up. A single weak point does not automatically condemn a worker to a bad job, and some vulnerable employees even report better outcomes on work intensity. But the accumulation of low pay, insecurity and weak rights leads to poorer prospects, less training, less autonomy and earnings that can swing from one month to the next. The mental toll is clearer still: highly vulnerable workers show higher rates of anxiety and depression, even if they are less likely to report work-related stress.
With the European Commission’s Quality Jobs Act still under consultation, the message is not exactly revolutionary. Flexibility may be useful, but only if it does not become a polite label for lower standards. Rules matter only when they are enforced, and that requires labour inspectorates that do more than admire the paperwork.
Written by Andreas Hofer andreas.hofer@alpineweekly.com




